Talk About Network

Google





Electronic Equipment > Digital Signal Processing (DSP) > Re: "Discrete H...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 3 of 44 Topic 14030 of 14426
Post > Topic >>

Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform"

by Richard Owlett <rowlett@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Oct 10, 2008 at 11:54 AM

julius wrote:
> On Oct 9, 9:02 pm, Richard Owlett <rowl...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> 
>>I'm interested in Magnitude vs Frequency.
>>I have a strictly Real input sequence.
>>There's Fast Hartley transform code available for my preferred language.
>>Relative speed is not an issue as I'm working on stored data.
>>
>>What gotcha's should I watch out for?
>>Is the a good comparison on the web of their practical differences?
>>
>>TIA
> 
> 
> Richard, maybe it's better if you tell us what your intended
> application
> is.  Right now it sounds a bit like asking whether you should buy a
> sedan
> or a hatchback :-P.  There will be lots of opinions, but they are
> worthless
> depending on your situation and application.

Well, my app is about as simple as it gets.
I have a time sequence f(t) and I want a measure of abs(f(omega))
Signal so far has been audio, but don't think that bears on question.
I'm not going to filter/process/... the transformed data, just plot it.
I have been using an FFT so far.
I wish to change hardware/OS/etc.
There is existing FHT code that I can cut and paste.
Wikipedia article seemed to imply FHT lost favor to FFT when faster FFT 
algorithms were developed.
 




 44 Posts in Topic:
"Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform"
Richard Owlett <rowlet  2008-10-09 20:02:59 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
julius <juliusk@[EMAIL  2008-10-10 09:12:59 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Richard Owlett <rowlet  2008-10-10 11:54:52 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-10 10:15:02 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-18 12:24:22 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-18 23:07:56 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-21 16:11:32 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-21 16:54:37 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Randy Yates <yates@[EM  2008-10-10 13:37:42 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-10 12:42:23 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Richard Owlett <rowlet  2008-10-10 14:48:45 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"VelociChicken"  2008-10-13 15:53:19 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-13 15:08:36 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-16 10:07:01 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"VelociChicken"  2008-10-19 15:41:35 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-16 10:12:18 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-16 13:19:36 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Andrew Reilly <andrew-  2008-10-21 00:04:49 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-20 18:48:06 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-19 08:03:01 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-19 08:14:36 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-20 14:21:09 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-16 10:17:13 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
clay@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-10-16 14:07:55 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-16 16:48:44 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-17 11:41:23 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-20 18:10:49 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-21 00:32:58 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-17 16:18:20 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"VelociChicken"  2008-10-18 00:46:48 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-17 17:21:33 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-21 11:30:46 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Eric Jacobsen <eric.ja  2008-10-21 13:46:01 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-18 12:03:16 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"VelociChicken"  2008-10-18 22:49:18 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-18 16:15:55 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-19 08:02:28 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Andrew Reilly <andrew-  2008-10-19 22:05:34 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
Jerry Avins <jya@[EMAI  2008-10-19 18:19:41 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"VelociChicken"  2008-10-20 14:34:10 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-20 11:46:09 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"VelociChicken"  2008-10-20 20:47:54 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"VelociChicken"  2008-10-21 13:46:55 
Re: "Discrete Hartley transform" vs " Discrete Fouuier transform
"Steven G. Johnson&q  2008-10-21 12:05:01 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
localhost-V2008-12-19 Thu Jan 8 21:14:02 PST 2009.